Geometry Advanced Class, Michaelmas Term 2025

Vafa-Witten invariants of projective surfaces

Organizers: Dominic Joyce, Pierrick Bousseau, Hulya Arguz, and Chenjing Bu

Wednesdays 9.30-11.0 in room C3, weeks 1-8, MT25

Vafa-Witten invariants are enumerative invariants of compact oriented 4-manifolds conjectured by the String Theorists Vafa and Witten in 1994. Notionally they should have a gauge theory definition - something like Euler characteristics of moduli space of instantons - but as the moduli spaces are potentially noncompact, this does not lead to a rigorous, deformation-invariant definition. For compact Kähler surfaces (better, projective surfaces), a rigorous definition is possible, due to Tanaka-Thomas and Thomas, roughly as invariants counting torsion-free coherent sheaves with Higgs fields.

   Vafa and Witten proposed that generating functions of Vafa-Witten invariants should have modular properties: they should be modular forms (or possibly mock modular for surfaces with geometric genus pg = 0, when there is a 'modular anomaly'). Modular forms are special functions coming from Number Theory. Their appearance in Vafa-Witten generating functions is surprising, and currently very mysterious geometrically.

  For surfaces X with pg = 0, the situation is different. Vafa-Witten invariants depend on the Kähler class of the surface, which defines a stability condition. String Theorists say the generating function of Vafa-Witten invariants should be modified to an 'almost holomorphic completion', which is non-holomorphic but exactly modular.

  When Vafa-Witten invariants of projective surfaces have been calculated (often modulo some conjectures), the modular properties have been confirmed.

Provisional programme:

Week 1: Sergey Alexandrov (String Theory guest speaker): short discussion of Vafa-Witten invariants in String Theory.

Weeks 1-2: Dominic: What are Vafa-Witten invariants? Sketch of gauge theory ‘definition’, Tanaka-Thomas 1,2 and Thomas. Try to get to modularity statement, at least for SU(2).

Weeks 2-3: Pierrick: Overview of the Vafa-Witten paper, quantum field theory origin of the Vafa-Witten equations, physics motivation: S-duality of maximally supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory, Vafa-Witten equations from topological twist. If time: relation with exceptional holonomy.

Week 4: Andrew Graham (guest speaker from Number Theory): introduction to (quasi) modular forms, and their relation to special values of L-functions.

Week 5: Hulya: Explicit calculations and conjectures for generating series of Vafa-Witten invariants of surfaces with pg > 0, in rank 2 and rank 3. Contributions of instanton and monopole branches to Vafa-Witten invariants, and discussion on modularity (in physics terms S-duality) exchanging these two contributions.

Weeks 6-8: TBA.

PDF files to download:

Programme